4 Reasons Electrolytes Are A Scam

Dr. Tom Gurney

By Dr. Tom Gurney

May 26, 2026

Summary: Electrolytes are real. The biology is sound. But for most people — most of the time — the threshold where they're actually needed is never reached. Here's what the science says.

1. The Physiology Is Real.

Sodium, potassium, magnesium, and chloride regulate fluid balance, nerve conduction, and muscle contraction. The problem is not the mechanism. The problem is that most people consuming these products are nowhere near the threshold where they actually need them.

4 Reasons Electrolytes Are A Scam

2. The Average Person Loses 500–900mg of Sodium Per Litre of Sweat.

Most electrolyte drinks contain 500–1000mg per serving. But the average gym session produces less than half a litre of sweat. And most people eating a normal diet already consume 2000–3000mg of sodium per day from food. (Shirreffs & Maughan, 1998; Journal of Sports Sciences)

4 Reasons Electrolytes Are A Scam

3. The Mechanism

Genuine dehydration → electrolyte imbalance → impaired nerve and muscle function.

But for mild dehydration, the primary deficit is water, not electrolytes. The perceived “boost” most people feel from an electrolyte drink? In the majority of cases, that’s just rehydration. A glass of water would have done the same.

4 Reasons Electrolytes Are A Scam

4. When They Actually Make Sense

1. Exercise over 90 min with heavy sweating — this is when sodium losses become meaningful.

2. Sauna sessions — significant sweat volume in short time.

3. The day after drinking alcohol — a strong diuretic that depletes sodium and potassium.

4. Long-haul flights — cabin humidity is ~10–20%, genuinely dehydrating.

5. Loading before a very intense session in heat — pre-loading sodium improves fluid retention.

If none of the above apply, drink water.

4 Reasons Electrolytes Are A Scam

All four reasons come back to the same thing.

The supplement industry builds products for edge cases and markets them to everyone. The 1% who actually need electrolytes aren’t who the ads are aimed at.

What actually moves the needle for most people? Sleep. That’s where the body rebuilds muscle, regulates cortisol, and clears metabolic waste. You can’t supplement your way around a broken night.

A Dutch brand called 8hours built SLEEP to address exactly this.

Skip to product information
Trust badge
  • SLEEP SUPPORT
  • REDUCED FATIGUE
  • NERVOUS SYSTEM
Trust badge
  • SLEEP SUPPORT
  • REDUCED FATIGUE
  • NERVOUS SYSTEM

Sleep & Recovery

60 Capsules (30 Servings)
An all-natural formula, designed for deeper sleep and faster overnight recovery
Deep Sleep
Fast Recovery
Fall & Stay Asleep
No Grogginess
Get up to 36% Off
Dr Tom Gurney

“The science is clear - quality sleep is the unfair edge for high performers”

Dr Tom GurneyChief Science Officer
CLAIM 36% OFF ON SLEEP

What To Expect When Taking 8HOURS SLEEP

Day 01

Foundational compounds begin absorbing

4 Reasons Electrolytes Are A Scam

Foundational compounds begin absorbing

Day 14

Nights Improve

4 Reasons Electrolytes Are A Scam

Your body starts to adapt to the foundational nutrients and compounds.

Day 30

Days Improve

4 Reasons Electrolytes Are A Scam

Better nights support your day-to-day energy levels, mental clarity, and mood.

Day 60+

Compounding benefits

4 Reasons Electrolytes Are A Scam

Sustained performance